Edinburgh’s Darkest Secrets: 5 Macabre Hidden Gems Most Tourists Miss

edinburgh city edinburgh castle

Edinburgh is often called a "city of layers," and nowhere is that more literal than here. While the crowds gather at the Castle or the Royal Mile, the true history of the city lies in the dark closes and subterranean vaults that have been walled up for centuries.

If you want to see the "Auld Reekie" that inspired Jekyll and Hyde, these five spots are essential—and entirely real.

1. The "Body Snatcher" Mortsafes (Greyfriars Kirkyard)

Mortsafe in Greyfriars Kirkyard, Edinburgh, UK
Image © Ghastly Guides, All rights reserved 

Greyfriars is famous for Bobby the dog, but its most "ghastly" features are the iron cages (mortsafes) found near the walls.

  • The Ghastly Fact: In the early 19th century, Edinburgh was the world leader in medical anatomy, but the supply of legal cadavers was low. This created the "Resurrection Men"—grave robbers who dug up fresh corpses to sell to the Medical School. Families had to pay for "watchmen" to sit in these towers or install iron cages over the graves to ensure their loved ones stayed buried.

2. The Thistle Chapel’s "Bagpipe Angel" (St Giles' Cathedral)

St Gile's Cathedral, Edinburgh, UK
Image © Ghastly Guides, All rights reserved 

Inside the magnificent St Giles' Cathedral is the Thistle Chapel, built in 1911. While the craftsmanship is world-class, it contains a very specific, quirky detail hidden in the wood carvings.

  • The Ghastly Fact: Among the intricate carvings of angels playing traditional instruments, there is a single angel playing the bagpipes. While it sounds charming, it was a bold inclusion at the time, as bagpipes were once banned in Scotland as "instruments of war." It represents a defiant nod to Scotland's bloody Jacobite history hidden within a Royal chapel.

3. The "Half-Hangit" Maggie Dickson (Grassmarket)

Grassmarket, Edinburgh, UK
Image © Ghastly Guides, All rights reserved 

The Grassmarket was Edinburgh’s main site for public executions. In 1724, a woman named Maggie Dickson was hanged here for concealing a pregnancy.

  • The Ghastly Fact: After the execution, her "body" was being transported back to her hometown in a wooden coffin when a local heard knocking from the inside. Maggie had survived the hanging. Under Scots Law, she could not be executed twice for the same crime because "God had seen fit to spare her." She lived for another 40 years, known locally as "Half-Hangit Maggie."

4. The Library of Human Skin (Surgeons' Hall)

Surgeon's Hall, Edinburgh, UK
Image © Ghastly Guides, All rights reserved 

Surgeons' Hall Museum holds one of the most macabre artifacts in the UK, linked to the city's most famous murderers: Burke and Hare.

  • The Ghastly Fact: After William Burke was hanged in 1829, he was publicly dissected. A pocketbook was fashioned from his skin, tanned to a dark leather. It is still on display today, embossed with "Burke’s Skin" in gold lettering—a permanent, physical reminder of the city's dark obsession with anatomy and crime.

5. The "Covenanters' Prison"

Greyfriar's Kirkyard, Edinburgh, UK
Image © Ghastly Guides, All rights reserved 

In the far corner of Greyfriars Kirkyard lies a section behind locked iron gates. In 1679, over 1,200 Covenanters (religious rebels) were held here in a roofless, open-air "prison" for five months.

  • The Ghastly Fact: They were given only 4oz of bread a day and no shelter during a brutal Scottish winter. Many died of exposure or were executed on-site. The area is now considered one of the most haunted places in the world, with documented reports of visitors suffering unexplained scratches and bruises—a phenomenon attributed to the "Mackenzie Poltergeist," the ghost of the man who oversaw the prisoners' suffering.

Uncover the Auld Reekie Mystery

Edinburgh’s history is too big for a single bus tour. Our Edinburgh Whodunnit Booklet turns the city into your own personal escape room. You’ll navigate the winding closes and steep wynds, solving a fictional mystery by finding real-world clues left by centuries of residents.

  • Avoid the Crowds: Explore at your own pace, away from the megaphone-wielding tour groups.
  • Authentic Research: We spend time thoroughly researching each ghost story and piece of dark history we put into our booklets.
  • Tracked Delivery: Your booklet is sent via Royal Mail Tracked 48, so it’s ready when you are.

Are you brave enough to walk the wynds? Order your Edinburgh Ghastly Guide for £14.99 here.

Back to blog
View all